PaperBoss vs PINS Advantage
PaperBoss vs PINS Advantage
PINS Advantage is a mid-market COI tracker with deep Procore, Sage 300, and Viewpoint Vista integrations and AI endorsement review. PaperBoss is the self-serve, transparent-pricing alternative for small and mid-size GCs who want COI, W-9, and WC exemption tracking without a sales call.
No credit card required · Cancel anytime
PINS Advantage (pinsadvantage.com) is a strong mid-market platform — they have an AGC of California partnership, customer logos like C.W. Driver and Morley Builders, and bi-directional integrations with Procore, Sage 300, and Viewpoint Vista. If you are a larger GC running enterprise ERP and processing 1,000+ COIs per year, PINS is worth a serious look. If you are a smaller GC who wants self-serve signup, transparent published pricing, and W-9 + WC exemption tracking included, PaperBoss is built for you. Both products handle the core COI workflow well; the choice is about scale, pricing model, and which documents you need to track.
Transparent published pricing
PaperBoss is $29 (Starter, 25 subs), $79 (Pro, 100 subs), $149 (Business, unlimited). PINS uses volume-tiered pricing based on annual COI count, starting around $1,000+ per third-party analysis — and you only see the quote after a demo.
W-9 and Workers Comp exemption tracking included
PaperBoss handles all three core GC documents (COI, W-9, WC exemption) in one workflow. PINS is COI-first; W-9 collection is not a headline feature on their product pages.
No vendor minimums or COI volume tiers
Track 5 subs or 500 on the same flat plan. PINS pricing scales with annual COI volume tiers, so growth means a bigger bill each year.
Self-serve signup in 10 minutes
Sign up at paperboss.io, add a sub, send a document request — all without talking to anyone. PINS onboarding requires a demo and quote first.
PaperBoss vs PINS Advantage
Comparison based on pinsadvantage.com solutions and pricing pages, plus SelectHub and Capterra third-party analysis. PINS does not publish pricing publicly.
Frequently asked questions
How much does PINS Advantage cost?
PINS does not publish pricing on their website. Third-party analysis (SelectHub) places the entry tier around $1,000+ and PINS uses volume-based tiers tied to annual COI count. You get a quote after a demo. PaperBoss publishes all pricing: $29, $79, and $149 per month with no vendor minimums or COI volume tiers.
Should I choose PINS Advantage or PaperBoss?
Choose PINS if you are a mid-market or larger GC running Procore, Sage 300, or Viewpoint Vista and you need bi-directional ERP integration plus AI endorsement review on high COI volume. Choose PaperBoss if you are a small or mid-size GC who wants self-serve, transparent pricing, and combined COI, W-9, and WC exemption tracking without a sales call.
Can I switch from PINS Advantage to PaperBoss?
Yes. Export your subcontractor list and current COI data from PINS, then bulk-upload to PaperBoss. Most GCs are up and tracking the same day. Email support@paperboss.io and we will help with the migration.
Does PaperBoss integrate with Procore like PINS does?
Not yet. PINS offers a bi-directional Procore integration plus Sage 300 and Viewpoint Vista. PaperBoss currently supports CSV import/export and runs alongside Procore; native integrations are on the roadmap. Most PaperBoss customers are smaller GCs not on enterprise ERP.
Try PaperBoss free for 14 days
Every day without tracking is a day you’re exposed. One uninsured sub can cost you the whole job.
14 days free · No credit card